Exilarch Ancestors

by Shawn Henry Potter and Lois Carol Potter
renatuspress.com

Exploring a Proposed Medieval Link to Ancient Babylon

Our documented family tree traces back through medieval French nobility to William II (Taillefer), Count of Angoulême, and his great-great-grandfather, St. William I, Count of Toulouse.[1] For over fifty years, historians and genealogists have debated an intriguing proposal by Rabbi Arthur Zuckerman: that St. William’s father, Theuderic, Count of Autun, was a Jewish prince who fled from Babylon to southern France in the 8th century.[2] This page does not attempt to prove the Babylonian-French connection. Rather, it examines how the later research of Dr. David H. Kelley refined, corrected, and strengthened aspects of Zuckerman’s thesis.

In Babylon, hereditary political leaders of the Jewish community were known as Exilarchs (Resh Galuta, or “Heads of the Exile”), a dynasty traditionally recognized by contemporaries as male-line descendants of King David.[3] While many genealogists conclude that the link between the Frankish counts and the Babylonian Exilarchs has not been proven with absolute certainty, the pioneering work of anthropologist and genealogist Dr. David H. Kelley, Fellow of the American Society of Genealogists (FASG), uncovered compelling evidence that keeps the theory very much alive.

Dr. David H. Kelley, Fellow of the American Society of Genealogists (FASG), uncovered compelling evidence that keeps the theory very much alive.

The Original Theory and the Academic Pushback

In 1972, Rabbi Arthur J. Zuckerman, PhD, published A Jewish Princedom in Feudal France, 768-900, presenting rabbinic and medieval evidence that the deposed Babylonian Exilarch Natronai ben Habibai resettled in Narbonne, France, under the Hebrew name Makhir.[4] Zuckerman further proposed that Makhir was identical to Count Theuderic of Autun—making St. William I, Count of Toulouse, and his Carolingian descendants heirs to the House of David.

Early academic reviews were divided between skepticism and admiration:

    • Dr. Robert Chazan: “The paucity of evidence, the questionable character of much of the material upon which Zuckerman builds, and the tenuousness of much of his inference combine to topple, for us, most of the edifice which he has constructed. Yet we must conclude by urging that A Jewish Princedom in Feudal France be read and pondered. The author has worked long and hard to gather all the relevant data and to weave them carefully into a case for his daring thesis.”[5]
    • Dr. Rebecca Wells: “Zuckerman has apparently exhausted the sources and has certainly presented a striking interpretation, albeit with much restraint. His work is thoroughly documented, with some sources quoted in appendices, and with a selected bibliography and a complete index.”[6]
    • Dr. Allan Harris Cutler: “Every page of Professor Zuckerman’s magisterial work will repay a careful study. Because of its uniformly high quality, A Jewish Princedom in Feudal France 768-900 deserves a place amongst the great classics of Jewish historiography in the 2nd half of the 20th century.”[7]

Twenty-five years later—and five years after Zuckerman’s death—historian and genealogist Dr. Nathaniel L. Taylor, FASG, published a major critique in The American Genealogist (1997). Taylor discounted several of Zuckerman’s weakest proposals—such as equating characters from French epic poetry (chansons de geste) with historical counts. Concluding that Zuckerman’s “dual identities” were unproven, Taylor dismissed the Narbonne origin story as unverifiable legend:

    • “We cannot now determine the validity of the Davidic origins of the Jewish dynasty in Narbonne—or even its continuity, or the names of the individual nesiim—before the eleventh century. Nevertheless the existence of the legend places this Jewish community in company with others whose traditions include assertions of Davidic links. David Kelley has reviewed equivalent traditions of Davidic descent among widely scattered Jewish families, and has noted in passing that there are some Jewish families extant today which may descend from this Narbonnais dynasty.”[8]

Because Taylor’s review was so compelling, many readers assumed the entire Babylonian-French connection had been put to rest. An important chronological point, however, is often overlooked. Taylor’s 1997 article evaluated Zuckerman’s 1972 book and cited only an early 1977-1978 article by David Kelley. Most of Kelley’s major contributions to the subject appeared later, in a series of studies published between 2003 and 2006. Kelley advanced substantially different arguments and introduced new chronological, onomastic, and prosopographical evidence. As a result, although Taylor successfully criticized several aspects of Zuckerman’s original reconstruction, he never addressed many of the arguments Kelley would later develop. Those later studies did not simply defend Zuckerman’s thesis; they corrected some of its weaknesses, abandoned several disputed identifications, and advanced new and significant evidence of their own.

David Kelley’s Discoveries: Separating Wheat from Chaff

Who was David Kelley, and why do his findings matter? David Humiston Kelley (1924-2011), PhD, FASG, was an internationally renowned scholar—famed as “a pioneer in key developments in the phonetic decipherment of Maya hieroglyphic writing” as well as “an expert in a large number of other academic fields, from astronomy to genealogy, and from ethnohistory to calendars.”[9]

Across four peer-reviewed articles—one in Toledot: The Journal of Jewish Genealogy (1977-1978) and three landmark studies in Foundations (2003-2006), published years after Taylor’s critique—Kelley tested every link in Zuckerman’s thesis with strict genealogical and chronological rigor, assembling independent lines of evidence from chronology, naming patterns, family reconstruction, Jewish dynastic traditions, and comparative analysis of medieval sources.[10] The discussion that follows examines four areas in which Kelley demonstrated that the evidence remained stronger than Taylor and other critics had recognized.

  1. Conceding Zuckerman’s Errors While Preserving the Core

In his 2003 study, “Was Solomon, Count of Roussillon, A Jewish King of Narbonne?,” Kelley partially agreed with Taylor that certain Zuckerman paleographical and epic-poetry equations failed. However, Kelley also identified several critical missteps made by Taylor:

    • Taylor had rejected the Narbonne delegation by citing a late romance date (759), whereas Kelley pointed out that the more reliable historical summary by Dumège dates it to 791, removing the chronological conflict.
    • Taylor argued that St. William could not have been the ambassador Isaac (who returned from Baghdad in 802) because “most scholars” date William’s capture of Barcelona to 801. However, Kelley demonstrated that the contemporary eyewitness poem of Ermoldus Nigellus contains explicit astronomical data proving the siege occurred in 803—meaning “most scholars” had misdated the event.
    • Kelley dismantled Taylor’s dismissal of the French chansons de geste (epic poems) by citing phonetic research (by Charles Bryant-Abraham) showing that the Hebrew/Aramaic name Makhir transforms regularly in Old Occitan (Langue d’Oc) into Macaire—a name that appears in the Charlemagne epic cycle (whereas Taylor had focused only on the names Aymeri and Magnario). Kelley further noted that Guillaume d’Orange in those epics mirrors the historical St. William down to specific biographical details (fighting in Spain, a wife named Witburg/Guiborc, and retiring as a monk at Gellone), proving the epics preserved real historical memory rather than pure invention.
  1. Brothers, Not Identical: Solving the Identity Problem

Zuckerman’s thesis had stumbled because he insisted Exilarch Natronai ben Habibai was the exact same man as Theuderic, Count of Autun. Kelley offered a far cleaner solution: Theuderic (known in Hebrew sources as Makhir) was likely the brother of Exilarch Natronai.[11]

Zuckerman had observed that the Hebrew name Makhir (מָכִיר) became a prestigious, well-known family name for centuries in Narbonne, marking Jewish leaders who claimed Davidic ancestry and the hereditary title of Nasi (Prince). Under Kelley’s model, multiple members of the Exilarchic family migrated west together around 768. Theuderic (Makhir)—likely brother of Natronai—married Alda (daughter of Charles Martel). One branch of their descendants integrated into the upper Carolingian nobility, while another branch established the recognized Davidic leadership (Nesi’im) of Narbonne. (Kelley even noted evidence from the Bollandists suggesting Theuderic’s daughter, St. Ida, married King Egbert of Wessex—making the Babylonian prince an ancestor of King Alfred the Great.)[12]

Kelley even noted evidence from the Bollandists suggesting Theuderic’s daughter, St. Ida, married King Egbert of Wessex—making the Babylonian prince an ancestor of King Alfred the Great.

  1. The Telling Evidence of Solomon, Count of Roussillon

Kelley argued that the strongest independent proof of Jewish-Carolingian intermarriage lay two generations later in Solomon, Count of Roussillon and Conflent (fl. 860s), a descendant of St. William. In an era when Frankish nobles almost exclusively named children after Germanic relatives, the sudden appearance of a powerful count bearing the Hebrew name Solomon—alongside his predecessor and close relative Sugnar (which Kelley linked to the attested Southern Levantine Jewish name Sugmar)—was striking. As Kelley concluded:

    • “It seems reasonably certain that both [Natronai and Makhir] were of the House of David (as then recognized) and likely descendants of the Exilarch Bustanai, of the 6th century CE, since it was alleged that he was the sole survivor of the Babylonian branch of the family.”[13]
    • “The adoption of Jewish names in the Carolingian empire still seems to me more suggestive of patterns of intermarriage than of a change in style.”[14]
    • “The anomaly of Solomon’s Jewish name is compounded by the possibly Jewish name of Sugnar [a previous Count of Roussillon], which is not biblical. To me it seems strong support for Zuckerman’s basic conclusion.”[15]
    • “The identification of Solomon as a Jewish King of Narbonne is essentially independent of Zuckerman’s other identifications and a priori the most probable of his ideas.”[16]

The following is Dr. David Kelley’s reconstruction showing how Solomon, Count of Roussillon, descended from Theuderic (Makhir), Count of Autun, and Alda, daughter of Charles Martel (dotted lines indicate proposed generational links).[17]

The following is Dr. David Kelley’s reconstruction showing how Solomon, Count of Roussillon, descended from Theuderic (Makhir), Count of Autun, and Alda, daughter of Charles Martel (dotted lines indicate proposed generational links).

Dr. Kelley’s discoveries regarding Solomon, Count of Roussillon, are significant. If Solomon was indeed a Jewish King of Narbonne, he would have inherited this title through his descent from Theuderic (Makhir), Count of Autun. Together, these observations led Kelley to argue that Theuderic was either identical to, or more likely the brother of, Natronai.

  1. An International Royal Dynasty: The Persian and Georgian Context

Critics of Zuckerman’s conclusions treated the idea of a Babylonian Jewish prince marrying into European royalty as inherently implausible. However, in his two-part 2006 study, “The Political Role of Solomon, the Exilarch, c. 715-759 CE,” Kelley dismantled that assumption by reconstructing the global reach of the Exilarchate.

First, Kelley demonstrated that medieval Exilarchic pedigrees—when properly separated from later lists of office-holders—independently corroborate one another across centuries, from Cairo Geniza fragments to surviving Dayyan family records in Aleppo. Kelley showed that the 8th-century Exilarchs were not isolated local scholars, but an international hereditary elite possessing vast trade wealth and double royal blood:

    • Dual Royal Descent: Through the 7th-century Exilarch Bustanai (c. 626-670) and his marriage to Princess Izdadwar—daughter of Yazdegerd III, the last Sassanid King of Persia—the Exilarchs were cousins to both the Umayyad Caliphs and the Shi’ite Imams.
    • Royal Intermarriage in the Caucasus: Kelley showed that Exilarch Solomon Rosbihan (d. c. 759)—great-uncle to the exiled Natronai and Makhir—married a Christian princess of Iberia (Georgia). This alliance explains the ancient, otherwise puzzling claim of the Georgian Bagratid kings to descent from King David, and shows that Exilarchic princes routinely formed dynastic marriages with Christian rulers. Far from being minor figures, these Exilarchs operated at the highest levels of Eurasian diplomacy: Exilarch Solomon Rosbihan not only married into Georgian royalty, but may have helped broker the Khazar Empire’s conversion to Judaism around 740.

When Exilarch Solomon’s grandson died around 767, a four-way succession crisis erupted in Baghdad. One claimant, Anan ben David, broke away to found the Karaite movement, while the deposed Exilarch Natronai and his brother Makhir fled west around 768—carrying their royal lineage and diplomatic prestige into the court of Charlemagne.

The following is Dr. Kelley’s reconstruction of the Exilarchic house from Exilarch Bustanai, his Jewish wife, and his Persian wife, Princess Izdadwar, down to Natronai, Counter-Exilarch, who fled to the West c. 768.

The following is Dr. Kelley’s reconstruction of the Exilarchic house from Exilarch Bustanai, his Jewish wife, and his Persian wife, Princess Izdadwar, down to Natronai, Counter-Exilarch, who fled to the West c. 768.

Documented European Descent (Autun to Angoulême)

Kelley’s later publications did not achieve scholarly consensus. Many historians and genealogists consider the evidence presented insufficient to establish the Babylonian-French connection conclusively. Nevertheless, Kelley argued that the cumulative genealogical, chronological, and onomastic evidence is stronger than many critics have recognized.

While not every scholar agrees with Zuckerman and Kelley regarding the Babylonian origin of Theuderic (Makhir), the subsequent lineage from Theuderic (Makhir), Count of Autun, and Alda, daughter of Charles Martel, to our ancestor William II (Taillefer), Count of Angoulême, is well documented in medieval chronicles and charters—connecting millions of modern descendants to one of the most fascinating families of the Middle Ages.

The following lineage traces six generations from Theuderic (Makhir), Count of Autun, and Alda, daughter of Charles Martel, through St. William I, Count of Toulouse, and Bernard I (Makhir), Count of Septimania, to William II (Taillefer), Count of Angoulême.

o   Theuderic (Makhir), Count of Autun, married Alda, daughter of Charles Martel. They were the parents of:

o   St. William I, Count of Toulouse, who married Cunigunde of Austrasia. They were the parents of:

o   Bernard I (Makhir), Count of Septimania, who married Dhuoda. They were the parents of:

o   Roselinde of Septimania, who married Vulgrin I, Count of Angoulême. They were the parents of:

o   Alduin I, Count of Angoulême, who married an unnamed wife. They were the parents of:

o   William II (Taillefer), Count of Angoulême, who married Regelinde of Gascony.

______________________

[1] For Lois Carol Potter’s descent see https://renatuspress.com/family/ancient-jewish-ancestors/. For Shawn Henry Potter’s descent see https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0BL5B6YN5/.

[2] Arthur J. Zuckerman, A Jewish Princedom in Feudal France, 768-900 (New York: Columbia University Press, 1972). https://www.amazon.com/dp/0231032986/. See also https://share.google/BhN7RB0GIqrPOCmdr.

[3] Jewish Encyclopedia, Exilarch. https://www.jewishencyclopedia.com/articles/5937-exilarch.

[4] Arthur J. Zuckerman, A Jewish Princedom in Feudal France, 768-900 (New York: Columbia University Press, 1972). https://www.amazon.com/dp/0231032986/. See also https://share.google/BhN7RB0GIqrPOCmdr. See also “Obituaries: United States: … Zuckerman, Arthur J., rabbi …” in The American Jewish Year Book, 1992, Vol. 92 (1992), pp. 590-604.

[5] Robert Chazan, “Review: A Jewish Princedom in Feudal France, 768-900 by Arthur J. Zuckerman,” in Jewish Social Studies, Apr., 1973, Vol. 35, No. 2 (Apr., 1973), pp. 163-165.

[6] Rebecca Wells, “Review: A Jewish Princedom in Feudal France, 768-900 by Arthur J. Zuckerman,” in The Historian, August 1973, Vol. 35, No. 4 (August, 1973), p. 641.

[7] Allan Harris Cutler, “Review: A Jewish Princedom in Feudal France, 768-900 by Arthur J. Zuckerman,” in Journal of the American Oriental Society, Apr.-Jun., 1977, Vol. 97, No. 2 (Apr.-Jun., 1977), pp. 207-210.

[8] Nathaniel L. Taylor, “Saint William, King David, and Makhir: A Controversial Medieval Descent,” in The American Genealogist 72 (1997), 203-221. https://share.google/oXejLWjiTmQBc7dsO.

[9] Peter Mathews, “In Memoriam: David Humiston Kelley.” http://www.mesoweb.com/reports/DavidKelley.html.

[10] David Humiston Kelley, “Who Descends from King David?,” in Toledot, the Journal of Jewish Genealogy, Vol. 1, No. 3 (Winter 1977-1978). https://share.google/a5mSiYWb2Y8xiipo8. See also David H. Kelley, FASG, “Was Solomon, Count of Roussillon, A Jewish King of Narbonne?,” in Foundations (2003), 1 (2): 75-80. https://share.google/2xTKdorEvL78T0fuu. See also David H. Kelley, FASG, “The Political Role of Solomon, the Exilarch, c. 715-759 CE (Part 1),” in Foundations (2006) 2(1): 29-46. https://fmg.ac/publications/journal/volume-2/category/46-fnd-2-1. See also David H. Kelley, FASG, “The Political Role of Solomon, the Exilarch, c. 715-759 CE (Part 2),” in Foundations (2006) 2(2): 140-157. https://fmg.ac/publications/journal/volume-2/category/47-fnd-2-2.

[11] David Humiston Kelley, “Who Descends from King David?,” in Toledot, the Journal of Jewish Genealogy, Vol. 1, No. 3 (Winter 1977-1978). https://share.google/a5mSiYWb2Y8xiipo8.

[12] David Humiston Kelley, “Who Descends from King David?,” in Toledot, the Journal of Jewish Genealogy, Vol. 1, No. 3 (Winter 1977-1978). See https://share.google/a5mSiYWb2Y8xiipo8.

[13] David H. Kelley, FASG, “Was Solomon, Count of Roussillon, A Jewish King of Narbonne?,” in Foundations (2003), 1 (2): 75-80. https://fmg.ac/publications/journal/vol-1/category/40-fnd-1-2.

[14] David H. Kelley, FASG, “Was Solomon, Count of Roussillon, A Jewish King of Narbonne?,” in Foundations (2003), 1 (2): 75-80. https://fmg.ac/publications/journal/vol-1/category/40-fnd-1-2.

[15] David H. Kelley, FASG, “Was Solomon, Count of Roussillon, A Jewish King of Narbonne?,” in Foundations (2003), 1 (2): 75-80. https://fmg.ac/publications/journal/vol-1/category/40-fnd-1-2.

[16] David H. Kelley, FASG, “Was Solomon, Count of Roussillon, A Jewish King of Narbonne?,” in Foundations (2003), 1 (2): 75-80. https://fmg.ac/publications/journal/vol-1/category/40-fnd-1-2.

[17] David H. Kelley, FASG, “Was Solomon, Count of Roussillon, A Jewish King of Narbonne?,” in Foundations (2003), 1 (2): 75-80. https://fmg.ac/publications/journal/vol-1/category/40-fnd-1-2.